He said it wasn’t in his job description.And it irked me.
My teenage daughter needed a ride to a friend’s birthday party. On the way, she wanted to stop by the drugstore to buy some makeup remover (a birthday party essential).
I’d had an especially long day and a trip across town with a tumultuous teen was not what the doctor ordered.
Me: Come on, will you take her?
Husband: We haven’t met the mom, so somebody’s going have to go in and talk to her. And makeup remover? Sounds like a “mom job” to me.
If someone issued strict parental job descriptions when we became parents, I must have missed the memo.
I’ve found myself doing a few “dad jobs” over the years, including plunging toilets, laying mulch, supervising contractors and various other “manly” jobs. Had I known, I could have just cruised through the carpool lane of mom life – feather duster in hand – without all those distractions!
I recently asked a friend whose opinion I respect about this “mom” vs. “dad” job issue.
Here was her take on it:
My husband is the same way. But I think it’s all in the way you look at it. I think what they’re really saying -- at least a lot of the time -- is this: “You’re better at this. Or, I’m not comfortable doing this.”
At my house, we don't necessarily always divide household responsibilities -- and certain aspects of parenting -- strictly by “mom” or “dad” jobs, but according to each of our strengths. It also depends sometimes on who's available (physically and/or emotionally) to do a certain task at the time it's needed.
I thought about what she said for a long time. And it made a lot of sense to me.
Certainly, God designed the family unit to work in a certain way and when the roles get too blurred, the family suffers.
But that doesn’t mean that Dad can’t take his daughter to ballet practice or that Mom can’t run a 5K with her son (did it a few summers ago).
I don’t want us to be so rigid that we can’t pitch in as needed outside of our traditional roles, as well as recognize and utilize each other’s strengths -- even if it means our house doesn’t look exactly like June and Ward Cleaver’s.
Sometimes there are aspects of family life that both parents are not strong at, but you just have to do it because it needs to be done. Doing what needs to be done – with God’s help -- to the best of our ability. That’s what parenting is all about.
I discussed my friend’s viewpoint with Mike and I think it helped both of us view the debate in a little different light. I then asked him if I could blog about it.
Yes, he said, as long as you don’t make me sound like a jerk.
So let me be clear. My husband is not a jerk. Far, far from it. And he has gladly performed more than a few “mom jobs” over the years. This is in no way meant to disrespect him. Neither of us are perfect. It's just one of those issues that has continued to crop up from time to time without satisfactory resolution.
But I think we’re getting closer.
Now I’m off to get a load of laundry for Mike to fold. I think he’s better at it.
How about you? Do you and your spouse ever struggle with this issue? I’d love to hear how you work it out in your family!









I get the "womans" job excuse a lot too. I agree tha tit is because they feel uncomfortable doing something. I use the "mans" job excuse anytime it comes to the car! =) So I guess it's ok...sometimes!
ReplyDeleteWe decided a long time ago we were partners in this marriage so the idea of working from our strengths appeals to me. We also know we have to learn each others' jobs too so we can help each other out. Took me a long time but I DID learn how to drive the riding lawn mower and actually found I enjoyed it. He has lately learned to cook! so it think there is more joy in not dividing up the jobs and just getting things done together!
ReplyDeleteI have a Mike that sounds very similar to yours! He was raised in a very traditional 1950's home, and his parents did have a strict line of division, especially when it came to parenting. Even though we have our struggles with the division of jobs, I know that he rose above that environment for the most part, because it could be so much worse.
ReplyDeleteHe is a laundry folding and putting away maniac, because I hate to do it. But he also wouldn't know where the kids' doctors office is located in an emergency, because he's never taken them. Shopping, haircuts, dentist - don't ask him. Sometimes that does annoy me, and we've talked about it too. Like everything, our marriage is a work on progress, so I'm sure we'll continue to deal with this.
One of my son's friends was over a couple years ago and Mike was washing dishes. This little boy gave us a clear view into his own upbringing when he said to Mike "Why are you washing dishes? Don't you know that's the mom's job?" I hope my boys are learning that there is no such thing as "mom's job".
It doesn't work in our family. It is really sad too... my 17 yr old has told me often she hopes to marry better than I did cause "dad won't do anything". The end result?... my girls are much closer to me than him. His Loss!
ReplyDeleteThere are some tasks that Mom do better than Dad; and same way for tasks where Dads are better than Mom....but when tasks are switched, that's when we realize how each other's job compliment one another.
ReplyDeleteJust wanted to say hi - and btw I enjoyed browsing through your writings!
I loved this post. We have a friendly (usually) joke around our house about what is a pink job and what is a blue job. I do a lot of blue jobs it would seem to me, but I am thankful for your friend's wisdom about receiving the delegation of a job as receiving a compliment of sorts. Sometimes that won't fly because believe me, there is no special technique to taking out the trash, and I am certain it has traditionally been a blue job, but it has to be done, and I can do it with a good attitude or a bad one. I try to remember that it is a good way for me to help my husband and then maybe he'll have more time for me and the kids with one more job struck off the list (regardless of the color). BTW my DH's name is Mike also. Hmmm there might be something to that.
ReplyDeleteHousehold responsibilities should be divided. That's the ideal plan.
ReplyDeleteThere's no woman's job. I think that is their excuse.
Hope you're having a great day!
B xx
That thing that gets me about my husband is for him to say, "tell the kids to do this." When they are there in the same room. Why does he not tell them himself, is a wonder to me?
ReplyDeleteMy husband may joke...but usually he is pretty good about sharing the responsibility with me. I am so blessed because of him...especially considering how he was raised. I think each couple has to do what works for their marriage/partnership. Some men married more "feminist" women...and they knew that. They were OK with that. Some women married men who prefer a more "traditional" arrangement. It's all about what works for your relationship.
ReplyDeleteP.S.
Thanks. Your post pretty much gave me the sign I had been looking for about a post I'd been considering. ;-)
We have an odd division of labor, but it works--I'm just better at some things than he is, and he's better suited for some jobs than I am. And he's quick to have me sit down and let him do something because he doesn't want me on my feet, or because it's too high for me to reach or too heavy (i.e. "a man job"). It works out pretty evenly because I do a lot of repair work around the house when he's working because I just won't leave it until he's off again. A lot of things, like errands and appointments, we do together since we share a car and we always take care of those things on off days. So I guess you could say we're fairly traditional with most things, but we help each other a lot too.
ReplyDeleteI have to confess, though... I think if he'd made the comment to me that your husband made to you, I wouldn't have handled it nearly as well as you did.
Melinda, totally relate. However, with my children grown, the chores are pretty simple. I let him wash the dishes, I let him take out the trash, I let him let the dog out early in the am and late pm, and a few other things......lol.... (The grass is his baby.) Tell your hubby, our men have all been there. :P
ReplyDeleteBig hot button Melinda! I agree with Jean about strengths and recognizing them. There still are times that I think something is "guy" thing and sometimes I'm embarrassed when my hubby has to iron his own shirt. I think this will always be a struggle.
ReplyDeleteMy husband works A LOT, so all the jobs are pretty much "mom jobs." lol. I often feel like he's the babysitter when I leave him with the kids, I have to give very specific instructions because he doesn't know their schedules, what to do about tantrums, etc...
ReplyDeleteSo it's a work in progress for us. The good thing for me is that he's willing to help whenever I ask him, and I just accept my current role as home manager and child expert (for my own kids, anyway!) I could spend time getting mad about how many diapers I change, but when I put my husband kids first, it works out!